7 Retirement Account Splits That Trigger Surprise Tax Bills

Image Source: shutterstock.com

Retirement money carries emotional weight. It represents decades of discipline, late nights, skipped vacations, and steady contributions that felt boring at the time but heroic in hindsight. When you divide those accounts—through divorce, inheritance, rollovers, or even well-meaning generosity—you step into a tax maze that punishes small missteps with very real bills.

Most people assume splitting retirement accounts works like dividing a bank account. It doesn’t. Tax rules govern every move, and the IRS does not reward improvisation.

1. Divorce Without a Proper QDRO on a 401(k)

Dividing a 401(k) during divorce requires more than a handshake and a settlement agreement. You need a Qualified Domestic Relations Order, commonly called a QDRO, and you must ensure the plan administrator approves it before any funds move.

Anyone navigating divorce should insist that attorneys and financial professionals coordinate the QDRO process carefully. Verify that the retirement plan administrator accepts the language in the order before finalizing it. That extra diligence protects both sides from a painful tax surprise that could linger long after the divorce decree.

2. Splitting an IRA the Wrong Way in Divorce

IRAs follow a different path than employer plans. You don’t use a QDRO for an IRA. Instead, you must transfer funds under a divorce decree and complete a direct trustee-to-trustee transfer into the receiving spouse’s IRA.

If someone withdraws money from the IRA and then hands it to an ex-spouse, the IRS treats that move as a taxable distribution. The account owner reports the entire amount as income.

A proper transfer keeps the funds inside the retirement system and avoids immediate taxation. When dividing an IRA, request that the custodian handle the transfer directly. Never let the money touch a personal bank account. That one decision draws the line between a clean transfer and a tax headache.

Image Source: shutterstock.com

3. Cashing Out Instead of Rolling Over

When someone leaves a job or finalizes a divorce, the temptation to cash out a portion of a 401(k) or IRA can feel strong. The money looks accessible and practical. But cashing out creates taxable income in the year of the distribution.

In addition, employers must withhold a percentage for federal taxes when someone takes a lump-sum distribution from a 401(k). That withholding does not necessarily cover the full tax liability. If the distribution pushes the individual into a higher tax bracket, the final bill can exceed the withheld amount.

A direct rollover into another qualified retirement account avoids immediate taxation. If you change jobs or divide assets, prioritize a trustee-to-trustee rollover and keep the funds inside a tax-advantaged account. Short-term relief from cashing out often leads to long-term regret.

4. Converting to a Roth IRA Without Planning for the Tax Hit

A Roth conversion can offer powerful long-term benefits because qualified Roth withdrawals remain tax-free. However, when someone converts a traditional IRA or pre-tax 401(k) money into a Roth IRA, the converted amount becomes taxable income in that year.

If a couple divorces and one spouse converts a large IRA balance without factoring in filing status changes or other income, the resulting tax bill can shock them. The conversion may push them into a higher tax bracket, increase Medicare premiums in future years, or affect eligibility for certain credits.

Roth conversions require careful planning. Calculate the total projected income for the year before converting. Consider spreading conversions over multiple years to manage tax brackets. Paying the conversion tax with funds outside the retirement account also preserves the full converted amount for future growth.

5. Overlooking Required Minimum Distributions in a Split Year

Required Minimum Distributions, or RMDs, begin at age 73 for most account holders, based on current law. If someone who must take an RMD divorces or transfers part of a retirement account during the year, confusion can arise over who must take the distribution.

The IRS requires the account owner to satisfy the full RMD for that year before completing certain rollovers or transfers. If the RMD does not occur, the IRS can assess a penalty.

When dividing accounts in a year that requires an RMD, confirm that the correct amount comes out first. Keep documentation that shows compliance. That step prevents penalties and avoids scrambling to fix a preventable oversight.

6. Gifting Retirement Funds Directly to Children

Some parents want to help adult children with a home purchase or financial emergency and look at their IRA or 401(k) as a ready source of funds. Once they withdraw money to gift it, they trigger ordinary income tax on the distribution.

In addition, a large withdrawal can push the parent into a higher tax bracket and potentially increase Medicare premiums under income-related adjustment rules. The gift itself may also intersect with federal gift tax reporting requirements if it exceeds the annual exclusion amount.

Instead of withdrawing retirement funds, consider other strategies. A parent might use non-retirement savings, structure a loan, or explore other financial planning tools.

7. Rolling After-Tax and Pre-Tax Money Into the Wrong Accounts

Many 401(k) plans contain both pre-tax contributions and after-tax contributions. If someone splits or rolls over these funds without understanding the distinction, they can create unnecessary tax exposure.

For example, rolling after-tax contributions into a traditional IRA can complicate future distributions because the IRA then contains a mix of taxable and non-taxable money. The IRS applies a pro-rata rule to IRA withdrawals, which means each distribution includes a proportionate share of pre-tax and after-tax funds. That rule can frustrate future Roth conversions and increase administrative complexity.

The Real Cost of Getting Casual With Retirement Splits

Retirement accounts reward patience and discipline, but they punish carelessness. Every split, transfer, or withdrawal carries tax consequences that demand attention. Divorce, inheritance, generosity, and career changes all introduce moments when retirement money moves, and those moments require strategy rather than instinct.

Which of these retirement splits surprised you the most, and have you ever faced an unexpected tax bill tied to one? Hop into our comments to talk about it.