7 Landlord Charges That Are Often Illegal But Still Collected

Image Source: shutterstock.com

Renting can feel like walking through a minefield sometimes. You sign a lease thinking you understand every detail, but suddenly there’s an extra charge on your statement that makes you do a double take. Some landlords slip in fees that aren’t just questionable—they’re downright illegal in many states. Yet tenants often end up paying them, either out of confusion, pressure, or sheer habit. From mysterious “processing fees” to outrageous penalties, the rental world is full of hidden traps that most people don’t even realize exist.

Understanding what your landlord can and cannot charge for isn’t just smart—it’s empowering. Let’s dive into seven common charges that landlords love to collect, even though they might be breaking the law by doing so.

1. Excessive Late Fees That Defy Logic

Late fees are meant to encourage tenants to pay rent on time, but some landlords push the envelope way past what’s legally allowed. In many states, there’s a strict cap on how much a late fee can be—sometimes just a small flat amount or a tiny percentage of the monthly rent. Yet, landlords often slap on fees that seem more like a financial penalty than a reminder. Tenants might see fees that double, triple, or even exceed their actual rent if they’re a few days late. The legality of late fees is tied to reasonableness; if it feels punitive rather than compensatory, it’s often illegal.

Documenting every transaction and knowing your local laws can prevent you from paying more than you owe. Remember, paying a late fee doesn’t mean you’ve accepted an illegal one—it just means you’re trying to avoid trouble while figuring things out.

2. “Processing” Or “Administrative” Fees That Have No Basis

Some landlords slap tenants with extra charges for things like processing an application, renewing a lease, or even simply updating paperwork. While some states allow small administrative fees, they often have strict limits. Charging hundreds of dollars for a routine document update is almost always illegal. These fees are tricky because they’re buried in lease agreements or rental invoices, disguised as something mundane. Tenants often pay them automatically, assuming they’re standard practice.

Understanding the fine print and questioning vague charges can save you serious money. If your lease is silent on such fees or if the fee seems excessive compared to the work involved, it may be unlawful.

3. Security Deposit Deductions That Don’t Add Up

Security deposits are supposed to cover damage beyond normal wear and tear, but landlords sometimes deduct funds for cleaning, minor scuffs, or even routine maintenance. Many tenants end up footing the bill for things that were the landlord’s responsibility from the start. States regulate what can be deducted, and landlords must provide itemized statements explaining the charges. Skipping this step or inflating costs can constitute illegal withholding. Keeping detailed move-in photos and written records can be your best defense. If a charge feels arbitrary or inflated, it’s worth questioning or even contesting. Many tenants don’t realize how much leverage they have when landlords overstep the rules.

4. Early Termination Fees That Break The Rules

Life happens, and sometimes tenants have to break a lease early. Some landlords impose huge penalties that go far beyond covering lost rent. While early termination fees can be legal if clearly outlined, they must be reasonable and reflect the actual costs to the landlord. Charging months of rent plus additional “processing” fees is usually illegal. Many tenants think they’re stuck paying because they signed the lease, but laws exist to protect you from unfair financial punishment. Negotiation is often possible, and in some states, landlords are required to mitigate damages by trying to re-rent the unit. Knowing your rights can turn a scary situation into a manageable one.

5. Utility Charges With Inflated Rates

Landlords sometimes bill tenants for utilities, claiming service fees or administrative overhead that far exceed actual costs. This can include water, electricity, trash, or gas. Many states regulate how landlords can charge for utilities, requiring them to charge only the actual cost plus a reasonable allocation. Tenants have been known to pay double or triple the fair amount simply because they weren’t aware of the rules.

Keep copies of all utility bills and invoices. If the numbers don’t add up, ask for an explanation—and know that in many cases, you’re entitled to a refund or adjustment. Transparency isn’t optional; it’s often the law.

Image Source: shutterstock.com

6. Non-Refundable Fees That Should Be Refundable

Some landlords charge “non-refundable” fees for things like carpet cleaning, key issuance, or amenity access. While a few fees might be legitimately non-refundable, many are not allowed to be labeled this way. If a fee is for a service that should be refundable or is required by law to be returned, calling it “non-refundable” doesn’t make it legal. Tenants often pay upfront, thinking there’s no recourse. Understanding what counts as non-refundable in your jurisdiction is crucial. Sometimes, pushing back or simply requesting clarification can result in the fee being waived or reimbursed. Don’t assume that just because a landlord says it’s non-refundable, it’s legally enforceable.

7. Penalties For Normal Wear And Tear

Landlords sometimes try to charge tenants for standard wear and tear, claiming it’s “damage” to the property. Things like faded paint, minor carpet wear, or scuffed walls fall under normal usage and can’t legally be charged to the tenant. Charging for these items is one of the most common illegal practices in rental management. Many tenants pay without protest because they assume they’ll lose their security deposit otherwise. Keeping records, photos, and move-in checklists can protect you from unjust charges. Being informed and assertive ensures you only pay for real damages that exceed ordinary use.

Your Landlord Experience Matters

Landlord-tenant relationships can be tricky, and knowing what charges are illegal can save you stress, money, and headaches. If you’ve ever faced a questionable fee or been confused by extra charges, speaking up is your best tool. Understanding your rights doesn’t just empower you—it can even prevent landlords from taking advantage of others.

We’d love to hear your thoughts or any experiences you’ve had with dubious landlord charges in the comments below. Every story helps make navigating rentals a little less daunting for everyone.